Kirkus Style Review

Red Clocks 

by Leni Zumas


When abortion, single-parenthood, and in-vitro fertilization are made illegal in America and complete personhood is granted to embryos, five women wonder: “What is a woman for?”

With the success of the television adaptation of Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale and the current political climate, feminist speculative dystopians have become a hot genre. Red Clocks follows the intertwined perspectives of five different women: Ro (“The Biographer”) an unmarried high school teacher trying to have a baby through IVF while also writing a biography of Eivør, a polar explorer in the 19th century; Mattie (“The Daughter”), an academically inclined high school student, who is struggling with an unwanted teenage pregnancy; Susan (“The Wife”) a depressed mother trapped in a unsatisfying marriage; and Gin (“The Mender”) a modern-day witch who provides herbal abortions. With these new laws, each character’s womanhood is threatened. This “ferociously imaginative novel” is so experimental and ‘imaginative’ in style, it takes an intense focus to parse. Zumas has created a world that feels plausible, teetering closer to contemporary fiction; yet, the fractured and almost messy nature of the narrative creates a distance for the reader. What should be an important and emotional character study is instead disconnected concept writing. It is as though Zumas cared more about playing with style than making a bold statement.

An intriguing premise that fell flat on creating an important, cohesive plot with poignant characters.


Comments